Inventory & Imports

Online Store Profitability: How to Calculate It Properly

Written by The StoreChart team7 min read

In short

Real profitability starts from net revenue: the order total with VAT removed. Subtract product cost, including landed cost for imported goods, the shipping you pay and payment processing fees to get gross profit. Then subtract operating expenses such as advertising, software, salaries and rent to get operating profit for the period.

Most online store owners can tell you last month's sales to the dollar. Far fewer have worked out their online store profitability and know what those sales actually earned. The gap is made of costs that never appear on the orders screen: the VAT collected on the government's behalf, the product's real landed cost, the shipping you paid on "free shipping" orders, the payment processor's cut, and the fixed costs of advertising, software and staff. This guide walks through each layer, gives the formula with a worked example, shows how StoreChart calculates it for every order, and lists the mistakes that make a store look more profitable than it is.

Why revenue is misleading

Revenue measures activity, not success. The store that sells more is not necessarily the store that earns more.

Example: two stores

Two hypothetical stores:

  • Store A: sells $100,000 a month at a 15% margin and keeps $15,000.
  • Store B: sells $50,000 at a 40% margin and keeps $20,000.
  • The result: the smaller store packs half the orders, needs less working capital, and earns more.

The figures in this article's examples are illustrative only and do not reflect actual customer data.

Costs that are easy to miss

The difference usually hides in costs that are easy to underestimate because they never arrive as one clear bill:

  • Tax inside the price. In Israel the order total includes VAT, currently 18%, which belongs to the tax authority, not to you.
  • Product cost. Not the supplier's quote, but the full landed cost of each unit, including freight, duties and fees for imported goods.
  • Shipping you pay. Including every order where the customer paid nothing for delivery.
  • Payment processing. A percentage of each card payment, set by your processor.
  • Returns and discounts. A refunded order still used up outbound shipping and handling time.
  • Fixed costs. Advertising, software subscriptions, salaries, rent, accounting.

Online store profitability formula

Work from the top down, in three steps:

  1. Net revenue = order total minus the VAT included in it, that is the order total divided by (1 + VAT rate).
  2. Gross profit = net revenue minus product cost, shipping cost and payment processing fees.
  3. Operating profit = gross profit for the period minus operating expenses: advertising, software, salaries, rent and the rest.

Margins are each profit figure divided by net revenue:

  • Gross margin: tells you whether your products and fulfillment are priced sensibly.
  • Operating margin: tells you whether the business as a whole is.

Example: a $300 order

Say an order comes to $300 after VAT is taken out, for two items.

Profit per product and per order

  • Product cost: the two units have a landed cost of $70 and $45, so $115.
  • Shipping: the customer got free shipping, and the courier charges you $12.
  • Payment processing: the processor keeps 3% of the payment, which is $9 once VAT is taken out of it.
  • Gross profit: $300 − $115 − $12 − $9 = $164, a gross margin of about 55%.

Operating profit for the month

Now scale it to a month of 500 such orders:

  • Net revenue: $150,000.
  • Gross profit: $82,000.
  • Operating expenses: advertising $30,000, software $2,000, salaries and rent $35,000. That totals $67,000.
  • Operating profit: $15,000, an operating margin of 10%.

The healthy-looking 55% on each order becomes 10% for the business. That is why both lines need watching.

The figures in this article's examples are illustrative only and do not reflect actual customer data.

How StoreChart calculates profitability

StoreChart runs the same formula on every order, using costs you set once per store:

  • Net revenue: VAT is removed from each order total at the rate configured for the store, falling back to the account's default rate.
  • Product cost: each order line carries the product's cost. A product's cost can be a fixed figure, a weighted average or FIFO, and goods received through the imports module arrive with their landed cost as the unit cost. The landed cost guide explains how that figure is built.
  • Shipping cost: each store has a shipping cost setting: none, a fixed amount per order, or an advanced calculation by product group. Pickup orders cost nothing, and you can override the figure on a single order.
  • Payment processing: each store has a credit card fee rate. It is applied to credit card orders only, on the order total, net of VAT.

The profitability report

The profits dashboard shows, for any period and for all stores or a selection:

  • The bridge to net revenue: from gross sales, through VAT, to net revenue.
  • Cost components: product, shipping and payment costs, then gross profit and margin.
  • Category breakdown: gross profit for each product category.
  • Orders with no cost: counted, so a gap in your data shows up as a warning rather than as a suspiciously high margin.
  • Product pages: units sold, revenue before VAT and profit for the period you pick.

Important

An order with no product cost counts its whole net revenue as profit. Before trusting any margin, clear the orders the dashboard flags as missing costs, starting with your best sellers.

Fixed costs and operating profit

Advertising, software and salaries do not belong to a single order, so they live in the expenses module:

  • Monthly tracking: each month's fixed expenses.
  • Invoice collection: supplier invoices collected automatically from Gmail.
  • Sending to your accountant: on a set day each month.

The invoice collection guide covers the setup.

The profit and loss statement

The profit and loss statement combines both sides. For a whole month, quarter or year it runs from gross sales down to operating profit:

  • Operating expenses: subtracted net of the VAT you can reclaim.
  • Comparison: the previous period sits alongside, plus a 12-month trend.
  • Whole periods only: fixed expenses are recorded per month, so the statement covers whole calendar periods.
  • Store filters: filtered to specific stores, it stops at gross profit, because fixed expenses belong to the business rather than to one storefront.
  • Provisional periods: a period is marked provisional while that month's invoices are still arriving.

What your accountant needs each month

Most accountants want the same package:

  1. Revenue and VAT for the period.
  2. The cost of goods sold.
  3. A list of expenses with the invoices behind them.
  4. A profit and loss figure they can check.

The profit and loss statement and the expenses module cover the first three together, and forwarding invoices on a fixed day means nothing waits for you to remember it. Agree with your accountant which period they need, and send closed months rather than the running one.

6 ways to improve profitability

Numbers are only useful if they change a decision. Common levers, in the order most stores find easiest:

  • Fix the cost data first. Missing or outdated product costs make every other decision wrong.
  • Look at categories, not just products. A category with high sales and a thin margin is where a price review or a supplier negotiation pays off most.
  • Check shipping policy against real cost. If free shipping costs more than the margin on small orders, set a minimum order value for it.
  • Compare payment methods. Card fees are a real cost; know what each method costs you before promoting it.
  • Watch return-heavy products. Better photos and more accurate descriptions often reduce returns more than any discount.
  • Judge advertising on operating profit. A campaign that raises sales but lowers operating profit is not working.

For the cost side of pricing, see the COGS glossary entry.

Mistakes that inflate profit

Five mistakes that make a store look more profitable than it is:

  • Counting tax as revenue. VAT in the order total is not yours.
  • Using the supplier price as product cost. Freight, duties and fees belong in it.
  • Ignoring free shipping. The customer paid nothing; you still paid the courier.
  • Leaving out card fees. A few percent of every card payment adds up.
  • Stopping at gross profit. Advertising and salaries decide whether the business makes money.

Key takeaways

  • Net revenue is the order total without VAT; gross profit subtracts product, shipping and payment costs; operating profit subtracts fixed expenses.
  • StoreChart calculates profit per order from costs you set once per store, and flags orders missing a product cost.
  • The profit and loss statement reaches operating profit for whole months, quarters or years across the business.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between gross and operating profit?

Gross profit is net revenue minus the costs tied to each order: products, shipping and payment fees. Operating profit also subtracts the fixed costs of running the business, such as advertising, software, salaries and rent. A store can have a healthy gross margin and still lose money at the operating line.

How does StoreChart calculate profit per order?

It takes VAT out of the order total at the rate set for the store, then subtracts the order's product cost, the shipping cost you configured for the store and the card processing fee for credit card orders. Orders with no product cost recorded are counted and flagged so they do not inflate the margin.

Where do advertising and fixed costs go?

Into the expenses module, which tracks the business's monthly fixed costs and can collect invoices from Gmail. The profit and loss statement subtracts those expenses, net of recoverable VAT, from gross profit for a whole month, quarter or year.

Why does my profit look too high?

The most common cause is missing product costs: an order with no cost counts its whole net revenue as profit. Others are counting VAT as revenue, forgetting the shipping cost of free-shipping orders, and leaving card fees out.

See StoreChart with your own store data

Open an account, connect your store and see your own numbers.